Topic Title Author Journal Pop. Covered TX Setting Instrument Findings
Behavioral health report card Performance Measures for Managed Behavioral Health Care Programs AMBHA Quality Improvements and Clinical Services Committee AMBHSA New Release    

 

 

AMBHA's report card

Looks at access to care, consumer satisfaction & quality of care for persons receiving managed behavioral health care services.
Best Practices What are Best Practices? Understanding the Concept Glazer, William M., MD Hospital & Community Psychiatry,Nov '94,V 45 #11    

 

 

 

 

This journal is beginning a quarterly column to provide "best practices." Good job of explaining the term "best practices.'

Children / Adolescents Psychopharmocology of Disorders in Children Sylvester, C Psychiatric Clinics of North America, 16 (4), 779-814, 1993    

 

 

 

 

Employment of lowest possible effective dose is important in medication of children with psychological disorders when considering side effect and stress reactions.

Children / Adolescents Managed Mental for Children and Adolescents Wanerman, L New Directions for Mental Health Services, 59, 13-26, 1993    

 

 

 

 

Managed mental health care can successfully yield high-quality treatments with reduced hospitalization and costs while increasing accessibility.

Children / Adolescents Day Treatment Outcome with Severely Disturbed Children Gabel, S; Finn, M; Ahmad, A Journal of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 27 (4), 479-482, 1988 Emotionally disturbed children Children's Day Hospital    

Abuse, parental substance abuse, suicidal ideation, and destructive behavior lead to hospital and residential .

Children / Adolescents Pharmacotherapy of Disorders of Adolescents Greenhill, LL; Setterberg, S Psychiatric Clinics of North America, 16 (4), 793-809, 1993    

 

 

 

 

The child's developmental process should not be harmed by the use of medication during therapy.

Children / Adolescents Adolescent Treatment Bergmann, PE; Smith, MB; Hoffmann, NG Pediactric Clinics of North America, 42 (2), 453-472 1995    

 

 

 

 

Posttreatment support essential for the success of adolescents leaving substance rehabilitation services.

Client - Tx Matching Symptom Severity and Utilization of Treatment Resources Among Dually Diagnosed Inpatients Ries, R; Mullen, M; Cox, G Hospital and Community Psychiatry, 45 (6), 562-568, 1994 Dually diagnosed Inner-urban hospital    

A history of substance abuse, leads to similar rise in symptom severity and treatment length as seen with current abusers.

Client - Tx Matching Medical Services Use by Patients Before and After Detoxification From Benzodiazepine Dependence Burke, KC; Meek, WJ; Krych, R; Nisbet, R; Burke, JD Psychiatric Services, 46 (2), 157-160, 1995 Former benzodiazepine detox patients Alcohol and Drug Dependence Treatment Program Medical records Benzodiazepine detoxification may reduce amount of outpatient medical and mental services used by patients.
Client - Tx Matching Inpatient Psychiatric Treatment for Depressed Children and Adolescents: Preliminary Evaluations Robinson, RM; Powers, JM; Cleveland, PH; Thyer, BA The Psychiatric Hospital, 21 (3), 107-112, 1990 Depressed children Child psychiatric unit Global Assessment of Functioning, Depression Self-rating Scale, Hopelessness for Children, Beck Depression Inventory, Generalized Contentment Scale, Index of Self-esteem Inpatient treatment yielded improved outcomes regarding depression, contentment, and self-esteem.
Client - Tx Matching Alcohol and Cocaine Abuse: A Comparison of Epidemiology and Clinical Characteristics Closser, MH; Kosten, TR Recent Developments in Alcohol, 10, 115-128, 1992    

 

 

 

 

The epidemiology and clinical characteristics of alcohol and drug addiction are presented and distinguished.

Client - Tx Matching Characteristics of Homeless Patients Discharged from an Intensive Placement Unit Silver, MA; McKinnon, K Hospital and Community Psychiatry, 44 (6), 576-578, 1993 Homeless patients Intensive placement unit    

Intensive community placement programs offer promise for discharged homeless patients by maintaining access to psychiatric care and shelters.

Client - Tx Matching Profile of 1300 Admissions to Central Neuropsychiatric Research Hospitals Whitmarsh, GA; Thorward, S; Muller, J; Cardona, E; Keskiner, A The Psychiatric Hospital, 17 (4), 191-194, 1986    

 

 

 

 

A central data set was established by cataloging 1300 patients at admission by 32 demographic and clinical variables.

Client - Tx Matching Long-term Course of Substance Use Disorders Among Patients with Severe Mental Illness Bartels, SJ; Drake, RE; Wallach, MA Psychiatric Services, 46 (3), 248-251, 1995 Dually diagnosed Mobile community-based ambulatory service Case Manager Rating Scale, Distinguishing between abuse and dependence has implications regarding prognosis and assessment.
Client - Tx Matching Defining Subgroups of Dual Diagnosis Patients for Service Planning Lehman, AF; Myers, CP; Dixon, LB; Johnson, JL Hospital and Community Psychiatry, 45 (6), 556-568, 1994 Dually diagnosed    

Structured Clinical Interview, Addiction Severity Index

The ASI is useful when determining which dually diagnosed patients would benefit from service planning.
Client - Tx Matching Special Populations: Women, Ethnic Minorities, and the Elderly Closser, MH; Blow, FC Psychiatric Clinics of North America, 16 (1), 199-209, 1993    

 

 

 

 

Problem conducting research that appreciates importance of cultural, gender, and agedness of subpopulations are hampered by internal variability, mutual exclusion and definitions of subpopulations.

Client - Tx Matching Differences in Social Class Among Psychotic Patients at Inpatient Admission Muntaner, C; Woyniec, P; McGrath, J; Pulver, AE Psychiatric Services, 46 (2), 176-178, 1995 Inpatient psychotics Metropolitan hospitals Duncan's Socioecomonic Index Patients of higher classes tend to not admit into state hospitals.
Client - Tx Matching Service Use and Costs of Home-Based vs Hospital-Based Care for People with Serious Mental Illness Knapp, M; Koutsogeorgopoulou, V; Hallam; A; Fenyo, A; Marks, IM; Conolloy, J; Audini, B; Muijen, M British Journal of Psychiatry, 165, 195-203, 1994 Severely mentally ill Psychiatric hospital    

Costs of the Daily Living are less than usual standard costs for inpatient treatment.

Client - Tx Matching Congressional Briefing Calls Attention to Mental Health Needs of African Americans unk Hospital and Community Psychiatry, 45, 837-838, 1994    

 

 

 

 

Problems regarding cultural factors that lead to differentiation of presentation of symptoms and access to care are discussed.

Client - Tx Matching Community Mental Health Staff Utilization in Washington State: Characteristics and Target Groups Peterson, PD; Cox, GB Community Mental Health Journal, 24 (1), 65-82, 1988 Mental health staff    

 

 

The changing demographics of mental health care staff and the resulting implications for targeting care to specific subpopulations is addressed.

Client - Tx Matching Diagnostic Criteria for Alcohol Abuse and Dependence Public Health Service Alcohol Alert, 30 1995    

 

 

 

 

Standardized diagnostic criteria are useful to clinicians by providing efficient assessment, and sensitivity in research and comparisons.

Client - Tx Matching The Current state of Psychiatry in the Treatment of Violent Patients Tardiff, K Archives of General Psychiatry, 49 493-499 1992    

 

 

 

 

Some violent patients respond to long-term psychotherapy and medication: carbamazepine, propranolol hydrochloride, and lithium carbonate.

Client - Tx Matching Contemporary Issues in the Treatment of Alcohol Dependence Collins, GB Psychiatric Clinics of North America, 16 (1), 33-48 1993    

 

 

 

 

Multiple levels of care are necessary to treat alcoholism with considerations for other medical / psychological problems and costs.

Client - Tx Matching Book review Mount, G Hospital and Community Psychiatry, 45 (7), 724-726 1994    

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Client - Tx Matching

Mental Health Service Use Among Homeless Men with Schizophrenia Caton, CLM Psychiatric Services, 46 (11), 1139-1143,1995 Homeless and homed schizophrenics Shelter, clinic, psychiatric inpatient programs    

Discharges for homeless schizophrenic men were inadequate in areas of planning for living , aftercare and finances.

Client - Tx Matching Predictions of Early Psychiatric Readmission Nicolson, R; Feinstein, A Psychiatric Services, 47 (2), 199 1996    

 

 

Patients with multiple previous admissions, low global functioning, violent behavior, and psychopathology are at increased risk of readmission.

Client - Tx Matching Current Needs vs Treatment History as Predictors of Outpatient Psychiatric Care Friedman, MJ; West, AN American Journal of Psychiatry, 144 (3), 355-357, 1987 Psychiatric outpatients VA Symptom Checklist-90, Denver Community Mental Health Questionnaire, Intake Scale, Social Adjustment Scale, Psychiatric Status Schedule Pattern of service use may be related more to help-seeking characteristic than clinical need.
Client - Tx Matching Lithium Compliance in Alcoholic Males: A Six Month Follow-up Study Powell, BJ; Penick, EC; Liskow, BI; Rice, AS; McKnelly, W Addictive Behaviors, 11 135-140 1986 Alcoholic patients clinics Psychiatric Diagnostic Interview Lithium treatment was not shown to be efficacious in reducing alcohol consumption .
Client - Tx Matching Psychotherapy for Substance Abuse Woody, G; McLellan, A; O'Brein, C Philadelphia VA Medical Center / Univ. of Penn.    

 

 

 

 

Psychotherapy is effective as substance abuse treatment in a univeristy-affiliated, research-oriented context.

Client - Tx Matching Behavioral Treatments for Drug Problems: Lessons from the Alcohol Treatment Outcome Literature Miller, W Research Monograph Series, 137, 167-180 1993    

 

 

 

 

Cognitive-behavioral approach to substance abuse therapy are established forms of cost-efficient clinically effective treatment.

Client - Tx Matching Therapy Strategies, Personality Orientation and Recovery from Alcoholism McLachlan, JFC Canadian Psychiatric Association Journal, 19, 25-30 1974    

 

 

 

 

The clinician's therapeutic strategy yields greater benefits when considering the patient's frame of reference and need for structure.

Client - Tx Matching Treatment Compliance of Older Alcoholics: An Elder-Specific Approach is Superior to Mainstreaming Kofoed, LL; Tolson, Rl; Atkinson, RM; Toth, RL; Turner, JA Journal of Studies on Alcohol, 48 (1), 47-51 1987 Alcoholics Class of '45 treatment program    

Subjects treated in elderly peer group remained in treatment longer and completed treatment more often than those in age-mixed peer groups.

Client - Tx Matching A Cognitive-Behavioral Approach to Substance Abuse Prevention Botvin, GJ; Baker, E; Renick, NL; Filazzola, D; Botvin, EM Addictive Behaviors, 9, 137-147 1984 Suburban seventh graders Public schools Life Skills Training The cognitive-behavioral program was effective when implemented by peer leaders or regular teachers for reducing cigarette smoking, excessive drinking and marijuana use.
Client - Tx Matching Peer Support and Education in the Comprehensive Care of Patients with Borderline Personality Disorder Brightman, BK The Psychiatric Hospital, 23, (2), 55-59, 1992    

 

 

 

 

Use of peer-support and psychoeducational programs are presented for use in care of borderline personality disorder patients.

Client - Tx Matching Alcoholism Treatment by Disulfiram and Community Reinforcement Therapy Azrin, NH, Sisson, RW; Meyers, R; Godley, M Journal of Behavioral Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry, 13 (2), 105-112 1982 Alcoholics Rural community outpatient clinic    

Disulfiram therapy was nearly 100% effective in cohabitating subjects but not with single subjects. The combined therapy was nearly 100% effective in all subjects.

Client - Tx Matching Helping Homeless Mentally Ill People: What Variables Mediate and Moderate Program Effects? Morse, GA; Allen, G; Calsyn, RJ, Kenny, DA American Journal of Community Psychology, 22, (5), 661-683, 1994 Homeless mentally ill Homeless shelter Admission records Continuous treatments provide better for homeless mentally ill offering intensive assistance in obtaining resources.
Client - Tx Matching Psychiatric and Social Reasons for Frequent Rehospitalization Kent, S; Yellowlees, P Hospital and Community Psychiatry, 45 (4), 347-350, 1994 Heavy service users (Australia)    

Hospital records

Mental healthcare should target resources to address social issues which promote use of services.
Client - Tx Matching An Integrative Ideology to Guide Community-Based Multidisciplinary Care of Severely Mentally Ill Patients Munetz, MR; Birnbaum, A; Wyzik, PF Hospital and Community Psychiatry, 44 (6), 551-555, 1993 Severely mentally ill    

 

 

Integration and coordination of services must overcome obstacle of opposing philosophies of care: psychosocial and psychiatric medical.

Client - Tx Matching A Checklist of Hospitalization Criteria for Use with Children Costelly, AJ; Dulcan, MK; Kalas, R Hospital and Community Psychiatry, 42 (8), 823-828, 1991 Psychiatric children Hospital Child Behavior Checklist Checklists provide guides for decision-making and reviews but offer no alternative to informed clinical decisions.
Client - Tx Matching Types of Alcoholics, I: Evidence for an Empirically Derived Typology Based on Indicators of Vulnerability and Severity Babor, T.F.; Hofmann, M.; DelBoca, F.K.; Hesselbrock, V.; Meyer, R.E.; Dolinsky, Z.S.; & Rounsaville, B. Archives of General Psychiatry, 49, pp. 599-608,1992. 321 male & female alcoholics pt. volunteers Volunteers from three residential Tx centers. a Veteran's Affair Medical Center, an alcohol Tx unit, & a free-standing mixed alcohol & drug Tx facility serving inner-city residents. Index & MMPI. Tx outcome assessed at 12 and 36 months; findings suggest that an empirically derived, multivariate typology of alcoholism has theoretical implications for explaining the heterogeneity among alcoholics and may provide a useful basis for predicting course
Client - Tx Matching Ethnic Differences in Emergency Psychiatric Care and Hospitalization in a Program for the Severely Mentally Ill Snowden, LR; Holschuh, J Community Mental Health Journal, 28 (4), 281-291, 1992 Adults with prior hospitalizations and history of difficulty entering system Entrance forms, clinical records Blacks use emergency and inpatient resources more often than whites.
Client - Tx Matching The Process of Recovery from Alcoholism Moos, RH; Finney, JW; Chan, Darrow Journal of Studies on Alcohol, 42 (5), 383-402, 1981 Married recovered / relapsed alcoholic and community controls Drink Patterns, Mood and Social Functioning, Occupational Functioning, Life Change Events Personal / Resources The functioning of alcoholics is similar to non-alcoholic controls.
Client - Tx Matching Research on Matching Alcoholic Patients to Treatments: Findings, Issues, and Implications Mattson, M.E. & Allen, J.P. Journal of Addictive Diseases, 11 (2),pp. 33-49,1991    

hing; and clinical issues in matching.

Client - Tx Matching Realizing the Potential of Practice Pattern Profiling Lasker, R.D.; Shapiro, D.W.; & Tucker, A.M. Inquiry, 29 (3),pp. 287-297,1992    

 

 

Reviews basic concepts underlying practice pattern profiling; describes roles that profiling can play in QI, assessment of provider performance, & utilization review; roles of profiling in achieving the goals of health care reform.

Client - Tx Matching Decision Support for Patient Care: Computerized Rating Scales Kobak, K.Greist, J.Jefferson, J.Katzlenick, D. Behavioral Health Care Tomorrow, Feb '96 Discusses the use of computerized assessment instruments for use in diagnostic interviews and rating scales. e - Compulsive Scale (YBOCS) Liebowitz Social Anxiety Scale; Quality of Life (QOL); SF-36 Health Survey e more honest & more likely to disclose embarrassing information to a computer. Preference of computer interview to physician interview differs by disorder.
Client - Tx Matching Types of Alcoholics, II: Application of an Empirically Derived typology to Treatment Matching Litt, M.D.; Babor, T.F.; DelBoca, F.K.; Kadden, R.M.; Cooney, N.L. Archives of General Psychiatry,49,pp.609-614,1992.    

 

 

 

 

Client - Tx Matching

A Chronic Disease Score With Empirically Derived Weights Clark, D.O.; VonKorff, M.; Saunders, K.; Baluch, W.M.; & Simon, G.E. Medical Care, 33 (8),pp. 783-795,1995 254,694 adults (18 & older) enrolled in an HMO is Western Washington State. Chronic Disease Score (CDS) revised. ter predictor of mortality than the ambulatory care groups; results suggest the revised CDS & ambulatory care groups with empirically derived weights provide improved prediction of health care utilization and costs, as well as hospitalization & mortality,
Client - Tx Matching The Role and Current Status of Patient Placement Criteria In the Treatment of Substance Use Disorders Treatment Improvement Protocol (TIP) Series (13) Center for Substance Abuse Treatment    

 

 

Delineates considerations for developing and implementing a Patient Placement Criteria (PPC) and the role of PPCs in research and Healthcare Reform. Provide good references, glossary and resource list.

Client - Tx Matching Preliminary Typology Designed for Treatment Matching of Driving-While-Intoxicated Offenders Wieczorek, W.F. & Miller, B.A. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 60 (5), pp. 757-765,1992. 156 DWI offenders from Probation Departments in Erie and Nassau Counties in New York, and from the Drinking Driver Program (DDP) in Erie County. erforming Tx matching with DWI offenders; 5 clusters suggesting specific Tx matching opportunities: 31% of cases showed a low problem profile, a moderate-severity group, a high-risk driver group, and two high problem-severity groups (these two had high le
Client - Tx Matching The Relationship of MMPI Subtype Membership to Demographic Variables and Treatment Outcome among Substance Misusers Filstead, W.J.; Drachman, D.S.; Rossi, J.J.; & Getsinger, S.H. Journal of Studies on Alcohol, 44 (5), pp. 917-922,1983. Re-analysis of two studies subjects consisting of 130 inpatients; 320 consecutive admissions to the LCSA participating in a family-focused study; & 116 cohort subjects selected from this sample. MMPI subtype membership was modestly associated with baseline sociodemographic variables but not with initial substance misuse or treatment outcome.
Client - Tx Matching Diagnosis-Related Group Refinement With Diagnosis- and Procedure-specific Comorbidities and Complications Freeman, J.L.; Fetter, R.B.; Park, H.; Schneider, K.C.; Lichtenstein, J.L.; Hughes, J.S.; Bauman, W.A.; Duncan, C.C; Freeman, D.H.; & Palmer, G.R. Medical Care, 33 (8),pp. 806-827,1995 4,114,840 adult hospital records of discharged pts. from all acute care hospitals in Maryland & California & a 20% national sample of records from the 1986 Medicare hospital claims files. Diagnostic-Related Groups revised. Discussed improvements in the DRG, like incorporating the severity of a pt's illness; becomes a synthesis of alternative pt. classification systems.
Client - Tx Matching Home-based versus Hospital-based Care for People with Serious Mental Illness Marks, IM; Connolly, j; Muijen, M; Audini, B; McNamee, G; Lawrence, RE British Journal of Psychiatry, 165 (2), 179-221, 1994 Inner London emergency inpatients with SMI Satisfaction: GAS, BPRS, PSE, DAH, BSO, SNR, NSN, self-report, proxy-report; Social Adjustment: Global, Social, Extended Family, Parents, Daily Living Skills, Economic, Work, Marital Over 20 months, home care was superior to standard outpatient care, was cheaper, and decreased duration of crisis admissions, but no long term improvement in client's condition persisted .
Client - Tx Matching New Directions in Research on Involuntary Outpatient Commitment Swartz, MS; Burns, BJ; Hiday, VA; George, LK; Swanson, J; Wagner, HR Psychiatric Services, 46 (4) 381-385, 1995    

Involuntary commitment shows limited success in reducing readmissions and length of stay.

Client - Tx Matching Matching Patients with Treatments: Conceptual and Methodological Issues Finney, J.W. & Moos, R.H. Journal of Studies on Alcohol, 47 (2),pp. 122-134,1986    

Outlines six key conceptual and methodological issues that underlie attempts to match patients with optimal forms of tx and to conduct research on pt-tx matching.

Client - Tx Matching Stay in Residential Facilities and Mental Health Care as Predictors of Readmission for Patients with Substance Use Disorders Moos, R; Moos, B Psychiatric Services, 46 (19), 66-72, 1995 Substance abuse patients Residential facilities Transitional community residential care and long-term supportive care improves substance abuser's outcome.
Client - Tx Matching Matching Clients to Treatment: Treatment Model and Stages of Change Marlatt, GA Assessment of Addictive Behaviors, 474-483, 1988    

A review of controlled studies that employed alternative treatments for successfully.

Client - Tx Matching Promising Themes in Alcoholism Treatment Research Allen, JP; Lowman, C; Mattson, ME; Litten, RZ Drug and Alcohol Abuse Reviews, 3, 33-64, 1992    

Advances in alcoholism treatment are presented. Assessing matched treatments often depends on the outcomes of interest.

Client - Tx Matching Access and Use of Health Services by Chronically Mentally Ill Medicaid Beneficiaries Moscovice, I; Lurie, N; Christianson, J; Finch, M; Popkin, M; Akhtar, M Health Care Financing Reviews, 14 (4), 75-87, 1993 Chronically mentally ill Medicaid beneficiaries Access to care slightly improved under prepaid plans with no decrease in utilization.
Client - Tx Matching Matching Problem Drinkers with Optimal Treatments Miller, WR, Hester, RK Treating Addictive Behaviors: Process of Change, 175-203, 1986    

 

 

Client - Tx Matching

The Effectiveness of Alcoholism Treatment Miller, WR; Hester, RK Treating Addictive Behaviors: Process of Change, 121-174, 1986 A strong study is required to have well-specified predictor variables, clearly differentiated treatments and adequate standards of improvement.
Client - Tx Matching Identifying Early Dropouts from a Rehabilitation Program for Psychiatric Outpatients Cohen, K; Edstrom, K; Smith-Papke, L Psychiatric Services, 46 (10), 1076-1078, 1995 Psychiatric outpatients Rehabilitation program Rehab dropouts can be predicted by the variables of hostility, bizarre affect, and personality disorder.
Client - Tx Matching The Diagnosis and Treatment of Alcoholism in Women Braiker, HB; The Rand Corporation Alcohol and Health Monograph, #4, Special Populations Issues, DHHS, '82 How treatment should reflect current etiologic model of female alcoholism is detailed.
Client - Tx Matching Effective Outpatient Drug Treatment Organizations: Program Features and Selection Effects McCaughrin, WC; Price, RH The International Journal of Addictions, 27 (11), 1335-1358, 1992 Non-methadone outpatient drug misuse organizations Telephone surveys, selection factors, and organizational and program features determine effectiveness of program.
Client - Tx Matching Outcome Pattern Matching and Program Theory Trochim, WMK Evaluation and Program Planning, 12, 355-366, 1989    

Theories of evaluation of matching by pattern and by outcome are discussed.

Client - Tx Matching A Computer-assisted Inpatient Psychiatric Assessment and Treatment Planning System Weiss, KM; Chapman, HA Hospital and Community Psychiatry, 44 (11), 1097-110, 1993    

Computer-assisted treatments are useful since it provides singular documentation, focuses attention given to symptoms and creates a large data base.

Client - Tx Matching Outreach to Older Adults: Matching Programs to Specific Needs Knight, BG New Direction for Mental Health Services, 52, 93-111, 1991    

A two-fold effort exists to outreach to the elderly: to educate the elderly of psychological problems and treatment and to educate mental health professionals about the elderly society.

Client - Tx Matching Matching Alcoholics to Coping Skills or Interactional Therapies: Post-Treatment Results Kadden, RM; Getter, H; Cooney, NL; Litt, MD Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 57 (6), 698-704, 1989 Alcoholics 21-day inpatient drug and alcohol abuse treatment unit Addiction Severity Index, California Psychological Inventory Socialization Scale, Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale-R, Wisconsin Card Sorting Test, Trail Making Test, Four-Word Short Term Memory Test For alcoholics higher in sociopathy / psychopathology, coping skills training was effective; for alcoholics lower in psychopathology, interactive therapy was effective.
Client - Tx Matching Mental Health Services: Utilization by Low Income Enrollees in a Prepaid Group Practice Plan and in an Independent Practice Plan Williams, SJ; Diehr, P; Drucker, WL; Richardson, WC Medical Care, 17 (2), 139-151, 1979 Low income PGP, IPP enrollees    

PGP enrollees achieved care twice as frequent as IPP, but IPP enrollees received care more often once care initiated.

Client - Tx Matching Expert Systems Restructure Managed Care Practice: Implementation and Ethics Brown, G.; Kornmayer, K. Behavioral Health Care Tomorrow Defines clinical information system (CIS); expert systems, treatment guideline, decisions support tool, & out management system. List the benefits & challenges of implementing a data-based care management system. Med-Query, utilized by Aetna, is software designed to for developing decision support capability. Authors list technical challenges, implementation barriers, and ethical & legal considerations but believe that the ability to incorporate outcome results rapidly back into decision-making tools and algorithms is worth the effort.
Client - Tx Matching A Review of Studies of Heavy Users of Psychiatric Services Kent, S; Fogarty, M; Yellowlees Psychiatric Services, 46 (12), 1247-1253, 1995 Literature review    

In most studies heavy users consist of 10 to 30 % of clients and use 50 - 80 % of the services; this group often is characterized as psychotic with comorbid personality disorder and substance abuse history.

Client - Tx Matching Case Management for the Mentally Ill: Looking at the Evidence Holloway, F International Journal of Social Psychiatry, 37 (1), 2-13 1991 Case management carries the potential to and affordably coordinate care of clients with appropriate clinical setting.
Client - Tx Matching Interpersonal Psychotherapy Weissman, MM; Markowitz, JC Archives of General Psychiatry, V 51, Aug. '94    

IPT is a proven / adjunct to medical care (acute, continuation, treatment.)

Client - Tx Matching Community Psychiatry Nurse Teams: Intensive Support versus Generic Care Muijen, M; Cooney, M; Strahdee, G; Bell, R; Hudson, A British Journal of Psychiatry, 165 211-217 1994 Severely and persistently mentally ill General hospital Global Adjustment Scale, Present State Examination, Brief Psychiatric Rating Scale, Social Adjustment Scale , the outcomes from a wide range of treatments do not differ for diverse social, psychological and medical profiles.
Client - Tx Matching Alcohol-Related Expectancies and Their Applications to Treatment Connors, GJ; Maisto, SA; Dermen, KH Drug and Alcohol Abuse Reviews, 3 203-231 1992    

Alcohol expectancies correlate to posttreatment functioning; these expectancies should be addressed during treatment and relapse prevention endeavors.

Client - Tx Matching The Science of Choosing the Right Decision Threshold in High-stakes Diagnostics Swets, J American Psychologist, 522-532 1992    

 

 

The (adjusting the criterion threshold of a continuous variable) is proposed for application in evaluation of mental health and mental health care.

Client - Tx Matching The Allocation of Drug Addicts to Different Types of Treatment: An Evaluation and A Two-Year Follow-up Segest, E; Bay, Hans American Journal of Drug and Alcohol Abuse, 15 (1) 41-53 1989 Narcotic abusers    

Hospital records

Results suggest MMT reduces mortality and increases number of convictions.
Client - Tx Matching Relationship between Alcoholism Treatment and Health Care Utilization Booth, BM, Blow, FC; Loveland Cook, CA Drug and Alcohol Abuse Reviews, 3 143-167 1992    

Long-term utilization should be discouraged when allowing recovery; although care is expensive, its use is often ; assessment should consider cost, treatment, and the client's ability to succeed under determined care.

Client - Tx Matching Savings in Hospital Bed-Days Related to Treatment with Clozapine Reid, WH; Mason, M; Toprac, M Hospital and Community Psychiatry, Mar. '94, V 45, #3 Schizophrenics State hospitals and inpatient centers Hospital records Large annual savings per patient are possible when clozapine in used causing a decrease in numbers of days of hospitalization.
Client - Tx Matching Variation in Alcoholism Treatment Orientation: Differential Impact upon Specific Subpopulations Lyons, JP; Welte, JW; Brown, J; Sokolow, L; Hynes, G Alcoholism: Clinical and Experimental Research, 6 (3), 333-343 1982 Alcohol treatment center Matching according to diagnostic criteria positively affects abstinence rates.
Client - Tx Matching Alcohol and Drug Abuse Treatment Of Homeless Persons: Results from the NIAAA Community Demonstration Program Orwin, RG; Goldman, HH; Sonnefeld, LJ; Ridgely, MS; Smith, NG; Garrison-Morgen, R; O'neill, E; Sherman, A Journal of Health Care for the Poor and Underserved, 5 (4), 326-352 1994 Homeless alcoholics / drug abusers Multisite demonstration program Addiction Severity Index Homeless shelters and outreach program are prime facilities to implement addiction rehabilitation programs.
Client - Tx Matching Effect of the Social Environment on Alcohol Involvement and Subjective Well-Being to Alcoholism Treatment Beattie, MC; Longabaugh, R; Elliot, G; Stout, RL; Fava, J; Noel, NE Journal of Studies on Alcohol, 54, 283-296, 1993 Outpatient alcoholism treatment center Psychosocial Functioning Index, Important People and Activities Inventory, Your Workplace, Perceived Social Support Early work on effects of social environment on drinking and treatment success.
Client - Tx Matching Predicting Response to Alcohol and Drug Abuse Treatments: Role of Severity McLellan, AT; Luborsky, L; Woody, GE; O'Brein, CP; Druley, KA Archives of General Psychiatry, 40 620-625 1983a Male alcoholics and drug addicts VA drug or alcohol programs Addiction Severity Index, Global measure of psychiatric problem severity at admission and treatment outcome were dependent.
Client - Tx Matching Evaluating Use of Continuous Treatment Teams for Persons with Mental Illness and Substance Abuse Teague, GB; Drake, RE; Ackerson, TH Psychiatric Services, 46 (7), 689-695 1995 Dually diagnosed Continuous treatment Substance abuse treatment should be into continuous care programs since they have been shown here to be effective and the of drug abuse is so high.
Client - Tx Matching Alcohol and Drug Abuse Treatment in Three Different Populations: Is There Improvement and Is It Predictable? McLellan, AT; Luborsky, L; O'Brein, CP; Barr, HL; Evans, F American Journal of Drug and Alcohol Abuse, 12 (1-2), 101-120 1986 Socio / age / sex mix of alcoholics VA, Inpatient Hospital, Psychiatric Hospital Addiction Severity Index Demographic variables do not strongly predict outcome in the presence of a treatment program.
Client - Tx Matching Home-based versus Out-Patient / In-patient Care for People with Serious Mental Illness: Phase II of a controlled study Audini, B; Marks, M; Lawrence, RE; Connolly, J; Watts, V British Journal of Psychiatry, 165201-210 1994 Seriously mentally ill Home-based (London) GAS, Present State Examination, Brief Psychiatric Rating Scale, Social Adjustment Scale, Client Satisfaction, Relative's Satisfaction Short-term benefits diminished over longer terms for both groups; however, satisfaction was higher in home-based care group.
Client - Tx Matching Determinants of Patients' Choice of Therapist Hollander-Goldfein, B; Fosshage, JL Psychotherapy, 26 (4), 448-461, 1989 Psychotherapy patients National Institute for the Psychotherapies Rating Scale After Half-Hour Session The process of selection is mutual, reciprocally in the dyad.
Client - Tx Matching Compliance of Homeless Mentally Ill Persons with Assertive Community Treatment Dixon, L; Freidman, N; Lehman, A Hospital and Community Psychiatry, 44 (6), 581-583 1993 Homeless persons with severe mental illness Psychiatric hospital and streets Assertive community outreach enables homeless persons with severe mental illness to adhere to programs for most all domains daily structure.
Client - Tx Matching Lithium Treatment of Depressed and Non-Depresssed Alcoholics Dorus, W; Ostrow, DG, Anton, R; Cushman, P; Collins, JF; Schaefer, M; Charles, HL; Desai, P; Hayashida, M; Malkerneker, U; Willenbring, M; Fiscella, R; Sather, M Journal of American Medical Association, 262 (12), 1646-1652 1989 Depressed / nondepressed alcoholics VA detox unit Addiction Seveity Index, Beck Depression Inventory Lithium had no effect on lowering abstinent rates in either cases or controls.
Client - Tx Matching Relationship between Role-Play Measures of Coping Skills and Alcoholism Treatment Outcome Kadden, RM; Litt, MD; Cooney, NL; Busher, DA Addictive Behaviors, 17 425-437 1992 21 day inpatient alcohol and drug abuse treatment unit Alcoholic Specific Role Play Test, Simulated Social Interaction, Drink Refusal Scene Both treatment regimens showed equally effects of lowering urges to drink and number of heavy drinking days.
Client - Tx Matching Comprehensive Clinical Services for Substance Abuse Treatment in and Inner-City General Hospital Galanter, M Hospital and Community Psychiatry, 44 (10), 991-994 1993    

Bellvue Hospital received the Gold Award for integrating a comprehensive clinical service program, including: dually dx inpatient, cocaine day treatment, MMT, a halfway house.

Client - Tx Matching Ethnicity Blane, HT Recent Developments in Alcoholism, 11, 109-122, 1993    

Research has neglected the ethnic hypothesis of addictive behavior.

Client - Tx Matching Definitive Treatment of Patients with Serious Mental Disorders in an Emergency Service, Part II Forster, P; King, J Hospital and Community Psychiatry, 45 1177-1178 1994    

Definitive treatment not minimal emergency care should become goal of emergency psychiatric care.

Client - Tx Matching Cocaine Abuse among Methadone Maintenance Patients: Are There Effective Treatment Strategies? Rawson, RA; McCann, MJ; Hasson, AJ; Ling, W Journal of Psychoactive Drugs, 26 (2), 129-146 1994    

MMT is the basis for cocaine rehabilitation, but should be supplemented by various supportive protocols (day centers, residential environs, inpatient.)

Client - Tx Matching Cocaine Abuse in Methadone Maintenance Programs: Integrating Pharmacotherapy with Psychosocial Interventions Avants, SK; Margolin, A; Kosten, TR Journal of Psychoactive Drugs, 26 (2), 137-146 1994    

Despite its benefits, MMT therapy alone does not effectively eliminate addictive problems, requiring supplemental therapies.

Client - Tx Matching Definitive Treatment of Patients with Serious Mental Disorders in an Emergency Service, Part I Forster, P; King, J Hospital and Community Psychiatry, 45 867-869 1994    

New medications are transforming emergency psychiatric care; follow-up care based in psychiatric facility reduces hospitalization length and improves integration into society.

Client - Tx Matching A Comparison of a Specialist Women's Alcohol and Other Drug Treatment Service with Two Traditional Mixed-Sex Services: Client Characteristics and Treatment Outcome Copeland, J; Hall, W; Didcott, P; Biggs, V Drug and Alcohol Dependence, 32 81-92 1993 Women alcoholics and drug abusers and mixed-sex comparison group Residential Opiate Treatment Index-Drug Use Scale, SADQ, SODQ, Beck Depression Inventory, Coopersmith Self Esteem Inventory, Social Network Inventory, Maternal Satisfaction Scale, Attkisson Client Satisfaction Questionnaire Both treatment programs differed only minimally in design, character and outcome; the gender-sensitive program is very similar and as effective as mixed-sex treatment.
Client - Tx Matching The Treatment of Disabled Persons with Alcohol and Drug Problems: Results of a Survey of Addiction Services Tyas, S; Rush, B Journal of Studies on Alcohol, 54 (3), 275-296 1993 Disabled alcoholics / drug abusers Community drug and alcohol treatment programs (Ontario) Despite large proportion of disabled in treatment population, no programs have been tailored to suit their individual needs.
Client - Tx Matching African-Centered Drug Treatment: An Alternative Conceptual Paradigm for Drug Counseling with African-American Clients Rowe, D; Grills, C Journal of Psychoactive Drugs, 25 (1) 21-33 1993    

drug patterns remain unlearned; low utilization of services will continue until consider the life.

Client - Tx Matching Relationship of Client Characteristics with Non-compliance in Methadone Maintenance Treatment Tommasello, A; Nilsen, K; Ball, J Research Monographs, 90 70 1988 Cocaine abusers Outpatient clinic    

Compliance improves drug-free outcome. Low methadone may lack efficacy.

Client - Tx Matching Clinical Services Research Attkisson, C Schizophrenia Bulletin, V 18, #4 '92    

 

 

The research of clinical services should concern itself with accuracy (and improvement) of dx, design of service, coordination of rehab with service, and effectiveness with regard to severely mentally ill.

Client - Tx Matching Disulfiram Implant: A Double-Blind Placebo Controlled Follow-up on Treatment Outcome Johnsen, J; Morland, J Alcoholism: Clinical and Experimental Research, 15 (3), 532-536 1991 Alcoholics (Norway) Alcohol treatment unit Oral disulfiram implants do not improve drinking outcome despite a decrease in psychological problems.
Client - Tx Matching Treatment and Follow-up Variables Discriminating Abstainers, Controlled Drinkers and Relapsers Elal-Lawrence, G; Slade, PD; Dewey, ME Journal of Studies on Alcohol, 48 (1), 39-51 1987 Problem drinkers (Britain) Sub-Regional Alcoholism Treatment Unit , reason for discharge and controlled drinking training were discriminating for a non-drinking outcome.
Client - Tx Matching Identifying Multiple Recidivists in a State Hospital Population Casper, ES Psychiatric Services, 46 (10), 1074-1078, 1995 Psychiatric patients State hospital    

Gender, compliance, homelessness, and history were related to recidivism.

Client - Tx Matching Predictor, Process and Outcome Variables Associated with Inpatient Mental Health Treatment of Children and Adolescents OTC Research Project unpublished Disturbed children Youth center thology Scale, Family Environment Scale, Vanderbilt Psychotherapy Process Scale A proposed research project to determine process and outcome variables associated with treatments received in a youth center.
Client - Tx Matching Home vs Hospital Care of Children with Behavior Disorders: A Controlled Investigation Winsberg, BG; Bialer, I; Kpietz, S; Botti, E; Balka, EB Archives of General Psychiatry, V 37, April '80 Severely disturbed children County and teaching hospitals tropolitan Achievement Test, Stanford Early School Test, Psychiatric Status Schedule, Family Functioning Checklist, Parent's Final Impressions Community care provides effective therapy regarding behavioral control and is as equally effective as hospital care concerning achievement, family functioning and parental satisfaction.
Client - Tx Matching Community Psychiatric Nurse Teams: Cost-Effectiveness of Intensive Support vs Generic Care McCrone, P; Beecham, J; Knapp, M British Journal of Psychiatry, 1994, 165 Hospital records Community psychiatric nurses generate higher costs but lower overall total costs when compared to community support teams.
Client - Tx Matching Variations in an Assertive Outreach Model Bond, GR New Directions for Mental Health Services, 52, 65-80, 1991    

Better documentation of program implementation will improve research and monitoring.

Client - Tx Matching A Comparison of the Effects of Sociodemographic Factors and Health Status of Outpatient Mental Health Services in HMO and Fee-for-Service Plans Wells, KB; Manning, W; Benjamin, B Medical Care, 24 (10), 949-960, 1986 HMO, prepaid plan enrollees    

Adults receive mental health care twice as often as children; The educated receive care more often than non-educated in fee-for-service.

Client - Tx Matching Postdischarge Follow-up of Psychiatric Inpatients and Readmission in an HMO Setting Schoebaum, SC; Cookson, D; Stelovich, S Psychiatric Services, 46 (9), 943-945, 1995 Psychiatric patients of HMO    

Readmission was less likely for men and women with follow-up visits; follow-up was associated with adjustment and affective disorder diagnoses.

Client - Tx Matching Pharmacotherapies for Alcoholism: Promising Agents and Clinical Issues Litten, RZ; Allen, JP Alcoholism: Clinical and Experimental Research, 15 (4), 620-633 1991 Many chemical agents exist to effectively alleviate problems during alcohol withdrawal.
Client - Tx Matching Factors Associated with Admission to Public and Private Hospitals from a Psychiatric Emergency Screening Site White, CL; Bateman, A; Fischer, WH; Geller, JL Psychiatric Services, 46 (5), 467-472, 1995 Psychiatric patients Mental health care emergency screening site Private hospitals tend to not admit patients that frequent public hospitals, but under a restructured system they may absorb a portion of this population and need to refocus their resources to treat them properly.
Client - Tx Matching Symptom Severity and Number of Previous Psychiatric Admissions as Predictors of Readmission Swett, C Psychiatric Services, 46 (5), 482-485, 1995 Acute psychiatric admittance State hospital    

Readmittants often exhibit high BPRS though disorder and self-neglect scores and high number of previous admissions.

Client - Tx Matching Heavy Utilization of Inpatient and Outpatient Services in a Public Mental Health Service Kent, S; Fogarty, M; Yellowlees, P Psychiatric Services, 46 (12), 1254-1257, 1995 Heavy users (Australia)    

Heavy users often are comorbid with personality disorder of longer treatments with poorer outcomes.

Client - Tx Matching Predictors of Receipt of Aftercare and Recidivism among Persons with Severe Mental Illness: A Review Klinkenberg, WD; Calsyn, RJ Psychiatric Services, 47 (5), 487-496 1996    

The interpretation of prognostic research should consider methodological and theoretical weaknesses.

Client - Tx Matching The Relationship of Pretreatment Family Functioning to Drinking Behavior during Follow-up by Alcoholic Patients McKay, JR; Longabaugh, R; Beattie, Martha; Maisto, SA; Noel, NE American Journal of Drug and Alcohol Abuse, 18 (4), 445-460, 1992 Outpatient alcoholism treatment center Alcohol Impairment Index, Mini-Mental Status of DIS, Family Assessment Device, McMaster Model of Family Functioning, Interpersonal Dependency Inventory Lower family functioning is associated with poorer drinking outcomes in men with low autonomy and is non-differential in women.
Client - Tx Matching Relapse to Substance Abuse: Empirical Findings Within a Cognitive-Social Learning Approach Annis, HM Journal of Psychoactive Drugs, 22 (2), 117-124 1990    

The cognitive-social approach to relapse prevention demonstrates efficacy.

Client - Tx Matching A State Management Planning System for Addressing High Levels of Use of Inpatient Psychiatric Services Seke, J; Hanig, D Psychiatric Services, 46 (3), 238-242, 1995 Psychiatric hospital admittance    

Large variation in hospital use and community services delivered occurred among regions of Washington state.

Client - Tx Matching Comparison of Behavior Therapy and Cognitive Behavior Therapy in the Treatment of Generalized Anxiety Disorder Butler, G; Fennell, M; Robson, P; Gelder, M Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 59 (1), 167-175 1991 Generalized anxiety disorder 12 sessions Hamilton Anxiety Scale, Watson and Marks rating scale, Leeds scales, State-Trait Scale, Beck Anxiety Inventory, Beck Depression Inventory Cognitive-behavioral was superior to behavioral therapy for measures of anxiety and depression.
Client - Tx Matching Alcohol Use by Heroin Addicts: Evidence for an Inverse Relationship. A Study of Methadone Maintenance and Drug-Free Treatment Samples Anglin, MD; Almog, IJ; Fisher, DG; Peters, KR American Journal of Drug and Alcohol Abuse, 15 (2), 191-207 1989 Anglo and Chicano male addicts California Civil Addict Program (in/out patient), county outpatient programs Methadone maintenance usually causes an increase in alcohol consumption when narcotic use diminishes in both ethnic groups.
Client - Tx Matching Comparison of Three Outpatient Treatment Interventions: A Twelve-month Follow-up of Men Alcoholics Powell, BJ; Penick, EC; Read, MR; Ludwig, AM Journal of Studies on Alcohol, 46 (4), 309-312, 1985 VA inpatients Global Assessment Scale, Alcohol Severity Scale Outcomes for this study were not associated with regimen, although psychosocial functioning improved.
Client - Tx Matching Patterns of Diagnosis and Treatment among Late-Middle-Aged and Older Substance Abuse Patients Moos, RH; Mertens, JR; Brennan, PL Journal of Studies on Alcohol, 54, 479-487, 1993 Middle-aged to older substance abusers VA inpatients Clinical records These men require especially more supportive treatment than younger counterparts.
Client - Tx Matching The Effect of Social Investment on Treatment Outcome Longabaugh, R; Beatie, MC; Noel, NE; Stout , R Journal of Studies on Alcohol, 54 (4), 465-487, 1993 Private outpatient alcoholism treatment center    

 

 

Client - Tx Matching

Comparative Effectiveness of Reducing Cocaine Abuse Among Methadone Patients Using Phase Lowering or Dose Reduction Wang, R; McCarty, M Research Monographs, 90 71 1988 Cocaine abusers VA outpatient center Drug-free outcome more likely with methadone treatment.
Client - Tx Matching The Natural History of Alcoholism versus Treatment Effectiveness: Methodological Problems Nace, EP American Journal of Drug and Alcohol Abuse, 15 (1), 55-60 1989 Long-term studies comparing treatments to natural history showed rates 25 times higher in treated group than non-treated group.
Client - Tx Matching The Integration of Empirically Derived Personality Assessment Data Into a Behavioral Conceptualization and Treatment Plan Collins, FL Jr; Thompson, JK Behavior Modification, 17 (1), 58-71, 1993    

The integration of personality data with idiographic-based behavioral assessments is suggested.

Client - Tx Matching Developments in Alcoholism Treatments Schmidt, L; Weisner, C Recent Developments in Alcoholism, 11 369-396, 1993    

The broadened concept of alcoholic problems has support of the scientific and professional communities.

Client - Tx Matching Comparative Cocaine Abuse Treatment Strategies: Enhancing Client Retention and Treatment Exposure Hoffman, JA; Caudill, BD; Koman, JJ III; Luckey, JW; Flynn, PM; Hubbard, RL Experimental Therapeutics in Addiction Medicine, 13 (4), 115-128, 1994 Black cocaine-abusing outpatients

ERR

Clinical records Program features (intensity, frequency, etc.) contribute to success of client.
Client - Tx Matching The Effects of Psychiatric Hospitalization on Behaviorally Disordered Children: A Preliminary Evaluation Geradot, RJ; Thyer, BA; Mabe, PA; Poston, PM The Psychiatric Hospital, V23, #1 Pediatric psychiatric patients University hospital Child Behavior Checklist Inpatient psych. group from marked increased in CBLC scores.
Client - Tx Matching Behavioral Treatment Donovan, DM; Marlatt, GA Recent Developments in Alcoholism, 11, 397-411, 1993    

The cognitive-behavioral theory of addiction has improved empirically-based treatment.

Client - Tx Matching Determinants of Children's Health Care Use: An Investigation of Psychosocial Factors Riley, AW; Finney, JW; Mellis, ED; Starfield, B; Kidwell, S; Quaskey, S; Cataldo, MF; Filipp, L; Shematek, JP Medical Care, 31 (9), 767-783 1993 Children and mothers under Columbia Medical Plan Pediatric clinics HMO computer records, Family Environment Scale, Family Life Events Inventory, Health Status Questionnaire, Child Behavior Checklist, Mental Health Index, Social Questionnaire Many family and social factors (depression, maternal pattern, family conflict, and many others) contribute to the amount of health care a child receives.
Client - Tx Matching Psychopathology and Substance Abuse: What is Being Learned from Research in Therapeutic Communities? De Leon, G Journal of Psychoactive Drugs, 21 (2), 177-188 1989    

The marked effects of drug on psychological problems requires mental health and substance abuse centers to accurately identify drug use as clients enter their programs.

Client - Tx Matching Aptitude-Treatment Interaction as a Framework for Research on Individual Differences in Psychotherapy Snow, R.E. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 59 (2), pp. 205-216,1991 Discusses what has been learned in ATI research on educational tx that should help ATI research on tx. ATI methodology takes individual differences among treated persons into account systematically in tx evaluation.
Client - Tx Matching Client-Treatment Interaction in the Study of Differential Change Processes Shoham-Salomon, V & Hannah, M.T. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 59 (2), pp. 217-225,1991 oriented ATI research; and other interactions to consider.
Client - Tx Matching Have All Won and Must All Have Prizes? Revisiting Luborsky et al.'s Verdict Beutler, L.E. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 59 (2), pp. 226-232,1991 bles whose interactions are potentially most important in patient, treater, and treatment interactions.
Client - Tx Matching Treatment of Aptitude X Treatment Interactions Smith, B. & Sechrest, L. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 59 (2),pp. 233-244,1991 e. Outlines a variety of stringent conditions necessary for adequate ATI research. ATI has the potential to produce research that will uncover previously hidden main effects more frequently than interactions.
Client - Tx Matching \ Dual Diagnosis. Clinical Treatment Matching Models for Dually Diagnosed Patients Ries, R. Psychiatric Clinics of North America, 16 (1),pp. 167-1751993    

Discusses 3 specific Tx Models: "Serial, Parallel, & Integrated, and matches specific disorders with each. Also discusses methods of improving each Tx Model.

Client - Tx Matching / Alcohol Abuse Issues in the Development of Client-Treatment Matching Hypothesis Longabaugh, R.; Wirtz, P.W.; DiClemente, C.C.; & Litt, M. Journal of Studies on Alcohol Supplement No.12,pp. 46-59, 1994 explanation, matches vs.