Planning for January 26, 1999 Meeting on the MHSIP Consumer Oriented Report
Card Consumer Survey
Issues to be focused on:
- Review various versions of the Adult Survey utilized in outpatient
settings (including psychometric properties and analyses as available).
Usefulness of the various versions from the perspective of consumers,
providers, family members, state and national level should also be addressed
.
- 40-item original survey, which includes negatively worded items.
- 40-item version of the survey in which the negatively worded items have
been reversed.
- 21 item version based on a factor analysis by Jack Wackwitz (Colorado),
Vijay Ganju and Tom Trabin). Testing by HSRI contractor for possible use
by NCQA.
- 23-, 25- and 29-item versions of the survey (currently being studied as
part of the 16 State Performance Indicator Study) – Judy Hall.
- Others, e.g., with similar items with variations on wording.
II. Review versions of the Adult
consumer survey being utilized in
inpatient settings.
Illinois version – 52 items
NRI ORYX version
Others, e.g., NY
III. Review versions of the Consumer
Survey being utilized with children and adolescents and their families
revised/adapted MHSIP adult consumer survey – Dorothy Webman
Modified Family Satisfaction and Youth Satisfaction Surveys, (Molly Brunk
and workgroup from the 16-State Performance Indicator Project)
Others
IV. Scoring of Survey
- Methodology for scoring and presenting data
V. Review methodology issues re:
administration of the survey
Consumer administered vs. administration by others
In-person vs. telephone vs. mail vs. web-based
Timelines for administration: discharge, 6 months etc.
Population surveyed – adults with serious mental illnesses, other
persons with mental illness, persons with alcohol and/or substance use
problems
Training of persons who administer the survey
Sample selection
VI. Addition of new items to cover areas
not previously covered by the survey
Recovery
Cultural competence
Others, e.g., dual diagnosis
VII. Translation of the survey into
various languages
What translations exist?
What was the methodology used?
Where are they being used?
Recommendations re: translation methodology and approval of translated
copies
VIII. Consumer survey tracking log and
development of procedures for future "official" approval of new
versions, including translations into new languages.
IX. Other
issues
- Public/Private Sectors issues, e.g. Performance Measurement Summit
- Relationship between the CABHS (Consumer Assessment of Behavioral
Health Services) and the MHSIP Consumer Survey
- Copyright to ensure public domain status
- Relation to HSRI-produced Toolkit
Outcomes Produced by the end of the Meeting:
Recommendations to the MHSIP Policy Group regarding the following issues:
- Which versions of the survey should be the "Official" versions
recommended by the MHSIP Policy Group for Outpatient and Inpatient Settings
and for Adult and Child and Adolescent Populations.
- The appropriateness of the survey for various populations served by the
mental health service delivery system.
- Guidelines re: who should administer the survey and under what
circumstances
- Recommendations re: when the survey should be administered
- Guidance regarding the translation process and official translation
versions cataloged by language, persons (agencies) responsible for
translation
- Guidelines regarding scoring and presentation of data
- Guidelines regarding involvement of consumers, family members and
providers in interpreting and presenting data
- Addition of items to the survey
- Tracking of different versions and approval of future versions
10. Guidance for revision and completion of the draft MHSIP Consumer Survey
policy paper
11. Guidance for Toolkit revision
Information for Distribution Prior to the Meeting:
¨ Vijay Ganju’s draft paper on the MHSIP
website
¨ Information produced by Judy Hall summarizing
work completed thus far on the 16 state pilot indicator project
¨ Information produced by Jack Wackwitz re:
factor analysis
¨ NRI ORYX information re: use of consumer survey
items
¨ Information from the HSRI toolkit
¨ Steve Davis’ proposal for tracking consumer
survey use and development
¨ Any other information produced by invitees or
others that can be reviewed prior to the meeting, e.g., NASMHPD State Profile
System summary of states' use of surveys
- Eisen, et al., Development of a Consumer Survey for Behavioral Health
Services. Psychiatric Services, June 1999, Vol 50, No 6, pp 793-798.
- Report by Carrie Kaufman on Survey of State Surveys